I believe one thing that can explain that dissonance between cynical readers like me and them is suspension of disbelief. Once you accept something as fact or take it for granted that It would happen,you don't think too hard.

Once my suspension of disbelief crumbles even a little,I start looking at the framework more closely and then find more things wrong with it. The only explanation for those manga readers is that their suspension of disbelief is crazy strong combined with the novelty of not reading every isekai like me.

It is for the same reason people like chinese xianxia novels,it's novel and new;that makes it exciting but then when you look more closely it's the same tropes and cliches done over and over in a different flavor.(the last statement applies to the MC of Ore dake Haireru)Always the same execution of the tropes,never done meaningfully or has any emotional impact.

It's also possible the repetition of tropes is comforting to them, so they keep coming back for more.

Maybe that's why this story isn't so well-received since I'm trying to make something different with the MC. 

That's what you get for killing a milf, a loli, and their whole fucking family  

and btw I'm not one of them, still have 5* on yours

Did he give feedback? One stars are like a 50/50 between trolls and people who read maybe 1-5 chapters and just came upon something they don't like and instantly rated it a one.

No, no feedback. I think there are around five new one star ratings and they don't really say anything. No one ever does really. 

Word count.net

A high Reading level only means they are using more words than fewer people understand. Don't boss yourself too much with that, and if you're worried about using too simplistic words, look up synonyms. 

It seems fine to me though. Can you perhaps tell me what chapters you use to grade them?

Just the two most recent chapters.

You have a patreon?

No.

Thats sad.

We can't always see the sun and the clear blue skies, there are nights and storm clouds that darken the sky.

In a book I read a few months ago, in the book's Afterword his author compares the writing of a story to sailing on a sailboat (without GPS) in the ocean that leads to some unknown place

In the Afterword to this book, the author also wrote that sailing with the sun, a clear blue sky and the sea breeze is a very good thing, but there is the night or storm that hinders navigation.

He also wrote that when night comes you have to try and guide where you are seeing the stars. And when the sky starts to get dark because of the storm that may come, the browser has to choose between:

If I understand correctly:

Fiora and Sherry best girl

And now Fiora's winning. I guess people really like confident girls like her.

Fiora & Sherry will have quit an interesting dynamic I think. Fiora is the confident one who won't be shy about her affections to Hugo and Sherry is the shy one who technically has first dibs on Hugo. Those two are likely going to clash quite a bit in the early stage of their relationship.

And now, Fiora and Marina's toe-to-toe again.

I'm surprised how many people are okay with incest. 

The last time I asked if people want to see Earth again relating to Hugo's original self, they all said no.

Well, want it or not, it's going to get brought up once 

appears.

Just looking at the summary, I can already tell it's one big touching character development for Subaru.

You know, it might be interesting if I make 

I could do something like that through an enemy that uses illusions.

Let's traumatize Hugo yet again. 

how long ago was that poll? and what site was the polls taken from? i can't point and laugh if i don't have a target! lol

that said marina sure is popular.

It's from QuestionableQuesting.

That poll is still open even to this day. I started it waaay back months ago when I first posted on that site.

Yeah, she is. Probably the most popular character for now. Gotta poll it again though to see if people's opinions have changed or not. A lot of readers who get through the first arc where she's a prominent character have stopped reading altogether. 

mmm, makes sense why the newer characters votes are abysmally low.

i mean i would think felicia would be more popular than nicole at least! lol

Yeah, Nicole doesn't even have that lovey dovey interactions with Hugo.

I'm still open to future possibilites.

Ah okay, I thought it was already pretty much locked in already, as I doubt Hugo is going for a large harem. What is the limit you've set?

The only limit is whether they will fit into the story or not.

Ah alright.

lemme guess, you plan to use their fetishes against them and black mail them to continue reading your story!

He is starting to change right now, but change is extremely gradual and slow. If you start changing Hugo too fast now, you actually undermine your own story.

Alongside that, you have a catalyst coming up that might have an influence in changing Hugo to become a more reliable and confident person, namely Sherry. Hugo was a major fact in giving confidence to Sherry, so why not turn it around and have Sherry play a major role in giving Hugo confidence in himself?

Exactly. I agree with all of that! 

Ah okay, I am curious who or what it will be then. I always thought it would be Sherry.

I already got an idea for that unique magic as well.

how will that impact the main story? by subtle changes to Ilymhyrra?

Can't tell you now. 

don't lie, it's not that you can't, but you simply don't want to~!

*eyeroll* well at least your enjoying yourself.

Inspired by how Rudy ends up marrying Eris, even though he no longer loves her at that point.

not sure i like where this is going. does it involve hugo feeling guilty?

i'd rather all of the wives have a good foundation for their relationship imo. it could also be a good means of why others may not have become his wives.

Let's just say it involves 

ah, that.