-
Conquer the world with traps. Votes: 19 4.8%
-
Embrace it. Votes: 45 11.3%
-
Become a sis-con. Votes: 41 10.3%
-
Conquer the world while being a sis-con. Votes: 72 18.1%
-
Why not everything? Votes: 220 55.4%
Where's the "try again for an actual girl's body" option?
I have noticed a change in your writing for the better as I read my way through the chapters. Honestly, the there is really only two things in your writing that pull me out of the book often enough to immediately bring it to mind.
1. Trying to follow who is talking to who at times can be frustrating since here is no clear indication of who is talking. The previous paragraph does not seem to always indicate who is talking to who.
2. When there is a change in POV and there is no clear delineation between the two vies. A simple ------------------------- on one line would make it a bit easier to identify the change.
Your characters for me are enjoyable and show that thought has been put into their personalities. I am looking forward to the chapters ahead of me. Keep it up!
I like it a lot, I think you're doing fine. I decided to go to bed, then I found this and read for 4 more hours straight. The only reason I wouldn't recommend it is because I like being able to read for a month or more at a time, but once you've written more and I don't feel like I'm getting someone addicted to a limited product I'd recommend it to anyone who likes fantasy
I think everyone has already said pretty much what I wanted to say, but I'm going to say it anyway. First, getting better at writing is a very long process. Yes, you're better than you were when you started this story, but you aren't so much better that if you worked on a new story for six months, you wouldn't look back at it with these exact same feelings having gotten better again. It's ok to make mistakes and produce bad writing, and it's a lot easier to edit bad writing than it is to write perfectly the first time, but if you can't push through and write even when you aren't feeling it or you've become ambivalent to your story, in the end you won't be able to write at all. Web novelists set themselves release schedules not because it gets them writing, but because it forces them to release even when they aren't ready, and I don't think that any actually good author is ever genuinely happy with a lot of what they produce.
You've said before that you think your story has a very shaky foundation, but I'm not seeing it. Yes, we still have very little information about the world, but it's normal for stories to release their setting and mysteries over time. It's even ok if there are things you need to go back and edit or even retcon - some of the top rated web fictions do that and people still love them - but I don't think you need to do that, because your setting is still being discovered by both the readers and the characters.
If I had any concrete advise to give, it's to sit down to write a story bible. In this document, you write down in detail everything you can about the story, the setting, and the characters, and then you stick to these details for the rest of the story. You ask questions like 'what are this character's formative memories?' and 'what does this character love/hate and why?', and you keep going until you have pages upon pages written. The reason is that the more you write about your characters, the more you get into their heads, and thus when it comes time to write their scenes, having them act in character will come naturally, even if you never directly reference any of those details in the story. As for the story, if you can get the broad strokes of where it is going, then go back and do a one sentence chapter by chapter outline of what each chapter includes, you can potentially do a lot of improvement to your pacing and direction. Well, if you have your own way of doing things that's fine too :)
Please don't give up on this novel, this novel is my personal favorite on this website, and I'm excited every time a new chapter comes out, now I know I have sh*t tastes in novels, but so do many people, don't get stuck just thinking what you could've done better and just look forward, and roll with it. You shouldn't feel pressured just because this series has gotten popular, it had gotten popular because of your original writing so don't try too hard to improve your writing or else you'll just hate your writing. You'll improve with time and practice, so don't self deprecate saying you shouldn't of posted it.
You're going to stop writing this?
I think I would pretty weirded out both by being attracted to my sibling and have the world attracted to *me* to the point where I can conquer it with traps. I'm a woman anyway so how would it even work. I'll go with choice number six, the immaginary dessert option. I like sanguinacchio. Yes, the immaginary sanguinaccio option.
Anyway.... why not work on shorter stories while you finish Craftsman? The unescapable fact of any long story is that you'll be a better writer after a hundred chapters, and then you'll look back at the beginning again and cringe at it, no matter if people like it or not.
Quick piece of advice, in order for something to be someone's favorite, it either has to be very good or very niche (and just happen to conform to the right person's niche. It will get you a smaller but stronger cult following.)
Personally, I don't think your writing's quite there yet for the former. Yes, it HAS improved A LOT since the early chapters, but not quite to the level of blowing people away. Then again, it's more the plot, premise, style, and characters that make it have that kind of punch and issues with writing conventions are often forgiven.
I mean it like. Now that I know what I am doing, I can actually plan a coherent narrative. Not really intending to blow people away with my writing. Just something coherent. Because this story had potato planning, and now that I got stuff down, the potato stick of a base is like a huge landmine that sometimes gives me huge blocks.
@Azrie Ok, I guess I can see that. Anyway, if you want my advice, don't go too heavy or serious with your plot. (Heavy and serious as in mood, not how seriously you take it.) Heavy and serious plots require a LOT of fore-thought and serious planning, and a style that fits. I don't think your currently at a level to make a plot like that work.
However, I DO think that a more seriously planned light-hearted plot (maybe like this one without the dissonnce of the back-drop of a poorly implemented cruel world environment. Honestly, I think it was the dissonance between the character attitudes and the backdrop that had me having so much trouble buying it on several points.) That would work well for you, and I think you could do well with such a plot.
Also, I would suggest you read the works of Nintailed_Furball, writer of "Reincarnated Vampire just wants to live a peaceful life" (Ironically named very similarly to yours and written at about the same time.) That series balances the plot and back-drop a lot better, and had a fairly similar direction to this one. I think reading that work could help you in your own writing. (FYI: My go-to advice for people working on their plotting is always going to be a reading suggestion. I will usually have a good one, and I think this is a good one for you.)
tl;dr, don't give up. You've improved a lot and there's so much more to go! Be happy you know things you can improve upon rather than being frustrated you can see them! I don't want to put anyone on the wrong path, so assume this is an incoherent rant vs actual advice.
Here's my 2c (more like tree fiddy). I'm still looking forward to updates, and while there are parts that could be improved, l'm still here reading every update! It's not perfect, but it's working at enough of a level to keep me anticipating the next chapter, so don't get stuck feeling frustrated. You can't please everyone so you may as well please yourself- wait that sounds lewd .
Re-writing is always an option, but I think it can be risky. You can get stuck in a loop trying to make it perfect, then burn yourself out completely. Like when you are learning how to draw, or build a base in minecraft or something. You can spend hours, days... weeks... or even longer trying to get it juuuuussst how you want it, but eventually you spend so much time on the small things you never get anywhere and, like most creatives seem to do, end up dropping the project altogether. I definitely think polish works, but you always need forward momentum, too. If you stop it's hard to start again.
Luckily, you aren't limited to one project! You can hold in your hand a lot of the things you learn and use that to make the next one even better. There is no either or, you can be greedy.
From experience it's rough when you see the art you've made, and focus on how lacking you think it is instead of getting excited you see so much you can make better. As a kid I got told my drawings were shit, so I focused so hard on what I lacked I never saw my improvements, and then I wasted 10 years thinking I had no talent and gave up. Now I imagine how good I could be if I had 10yrs of practice! Also one last observation for everyone out there that I personally experience: Breaks can be great, but they can also kill motivation. I think while you are still chasing that serotonin high creativity gives you, your brain compels you do make more art, but once you starve your brain of that hit for a while, it gives up and looks somewhere else for that high. That high is what motivates us, so we gotta hijack it when we can since brute forcing is hard as heck.
EDIT: spellcheck at my cute blobs
I wouldn't have made some of the choices. E.g: Heterochromia - I honestly forget eye descriptions when reading stories, heck even watching shows unless it's some eye power or its referenced a lot
This. I was seriously thinking "Wait, did someone have Heterochromia in this story?"
@Arkus86 Well, it's always in the back of my mind. Mostly because of the cover, but also because it's a rather eye-catching thing in the world.
@Azrie Yeah, I'm one of those who has trouble remembering descriptions, eye descriptions in particular, and I mixed it up with the story mentioned by Jemini and just gave her red eyes in my mind
@Arkus86 I'm in the same boat. eye's just don't matter unless I'm physically close enough to said person, or they glow. Out on the street? I couldn't tell you anyone's eye color, heterochomia or not.
To be fair, I have a static filter in my eye sight, that goes blue to red. Imagine a tv static screen. change the black to blue, and the white to red. Then put that at about 92~% transparency and that's a good indication as to what I deal with. I can't tell a different between 720p and 4k. I can't tell the difference between 32FPS and 120FPS. Nor can I tell a diff between pure white and antique white.
If Naruto was a novel instead of a manga or anime, I would have been screwed over all the different eye powers.