It's nice, imo; a xianxia-like Hogwarts iykwim; the MC not knowing much gives this a nice touch, and as such gets up to, in retrospect cringy, shenanigans.

If the title was 'Andy's Shenanigans in Hogwarts', it would've made so much sense.

Give it a light read and treat it like the light reat it is.

Also, unlike the some uninteresting reader's review, imo, not having knowledge of the plot isn't a plot hole; he doesn't magically (pun intended) know about the chamber of secrets and ginny's diary, or about the Rat animagus that Ron keeps around, he doesn't know the triwizard will happen, nor does he know about either Snape's true past, umb (ich) ridge, or even the invinisibility cape harry will have; he doens't know about the marauder's map, about dumbles' death, voldemort's various plots, seriously, MC only knows about the one book he apparently knows about and moves with that knowledge. It's not a plot plot, and it's enjoyable to read his feelings and thoughts about it, without knowing the true danger voldy can unleash on the poor lad.

As for the system being unhelpful? Please. As soon as a system doesn't make the MC super OP in a couple of chapters these types of guys start yapping around. The way I see it, the way it's set up is for the long haul -- it'll take years' work before he becomes anywhere OP and that's more enjoyable than suddenly spewing out seventh year charm spells left and right after just two months of training at home. I'd know; I'm a fan 

Update:

Ok, I take back my previous remarks; the MC really does have so many eerily accurate 'deductions' it's like he knows the plot itself. At this point there is no point to having a plot-unaware MC. Be that as it may, the story itself is fairly readable and a nice relaxing read. Give it a try before making any assumptions -- it's like a chinese Hogwarts and in an amusing way at that.

Read More

Honestly a gem lol. I didn't expect to find this as much fun as I did, but it really has a unique premise compared to other Isekai hp fanfics. The MC only has watched movie 1, so his understanding of the world is limited. I found the recent chapters to be really funny too-

Overall, it's a fun read, would recommend checking it out.

Read More

Translation is well done

I like the MC's approach to relationships and his dedication to improving  and especially that he avoids needlessly endangering himself

References to Chinese figures or idioms are not explained hence waste of words

No racism as far as I could see, which is pretty rare

I like the system it's not instant-op but requires work to reach op status

Tldr: For a HP fanfic it's pretty damn good

Read More

• Translation: 3.4/5, it's understandable, but sentences are often awkward and keep a distinct chinese accent that can be off-putting for english natives.
• Story enjoyment: 2.5/5, MC's HP knowledge is a huge plot hole. He supposedly only knows about the first book, but he often references stuff that happens in the later books with "guesses" that are always accurate? + The system is kinda trash IMO.

Read More