5. Why
594 6 57
X
Reading Options
Font Size
A- 15px A+
Width
Reset
X
Table of Contents
Loading... please wait.

Lena didn’t let the kitchen get its hooks in them.

Jamie finished the Cheerios, and the second his bowl was empty the calm started to feel thin again, like it had been borrowed. Lena saw it in the way his shoulders crept up and his fingers curled around her hand.

She stood first, casual on the surface.

“Okay,” she said, brisk. “We’re going back upstairs.”

Aunt Penny blinked. “Lena—”

“No,” Lena said, not rude, just firm. “Not done yet.”

Uncle Alex opened his mouth like he had a joke queued up and then thought better of it. His parents didn’’t say anything. Jamie didn’t look at them. He couldn’t. Not without his stomach twisting.

Lena’s hand found his wrist under the table. Steady. Warm.

“Come on,” she said quietly.

Jamie rose. The varsity hoodie shifted on his shoulders, heavy with her scent, and that alone made his thoughts skid.

Lena moved in close—shoulder to shoulder, a human guardrail—and guided him to the stairs.

Behind them, Aunt Penny’’s voice floated softly, careful. “We’ll be down here.”

His mom added, even softer, “If you need anything.”

Jamie nodded without looking back.

He followed Lena up.

Outside her door, Lena stopped and took a breath like she was about to walk into a storm.

“Okay,” she said, low and serious. “House rules for this conversation.”

Jamie blinked. “Conversation rules?”

“Yes.” Lena held up one finger. “One: you’re not going to run away. If you try, I’m going to block the door.”

A second finger. “Two: we can pause whenever. If either of us starts spiraling, we stop, drink water, breathe, and then keep going.”

A third finger. “Three: we are not doing vague. You don’t get to say “I don’t know” when you actually do.”

Jamie’s stomach dipped.

“And four,” Lena said, voice softer now, “you don’t get to say anything cruel about yourself and call it honesty. If you start doing that, I’m going to tell you to shut up.”

Jamie stared at her.

Lena looked back, stubborn and a little scared, like she was bracing for him to vanish again.

“Okay?” she asked.

Jamie swallowed. “Okay.”

Lena nodded once, like that was a contract.

Then she opened the door and towed him in.

The room was bright with morning. Desk. Dock. Two monitors. The rest was background noise Jamie didn’t have the nerve to really take in yet.

Lena shut the door and didn’t lock it. She didn’t need to.

“Sit,” she said.

Jamie sat on the edge of her bed, hands half-hidden in the sleeves of her hoodie.

Lena crossed the room, grabbed her sticker-covered Nalgene, and shoved it into his hands.

“Drink.”

Jamie obeyed. A few swallows.

Lena took it back, set it down, then sat close—near enough to feel, not quite touching. She looked at him for a long second.

Jamie couldn’t take the silence. He said the first thing that came out, softer than he meant it.

“We slept good.”

Lena’s mouth twitched. A real, small smile. “Yeah,” she said, like she couldn’t quite believe it. “We did.”

Then she snapped back into focus, fingers tapping once against her knee like a reset.

“Start,” she said.

Jamie’s throat tightened. “Start what?”

“Start at the part where you tell me what happened,” Lena said, steady. “Because I’m not doing another four years of wondering why my best friend just… stopped loving me.”

Jamie flinched.

Lena’s eyes narrowed. “Rule three.”

Jamie stared down at his hands. His fingers rubbed the stitched edge of her name like it could steady him.

“I don’t know how to—” he started.

“Try anyway,” Lena said.

Jamie shut his eyes.

A memory hit him, sharp as glass: fourteen, on Lena’s porch steps, his voice cracking mid-sentence, the humiliation like bile in his throat. Lena laughed, bright and automatic, not even at him, just at the world, and it made something in him go hot and poisonous.

“Must be nice,” he’d spat.

And then he’d kept going, because stopping would’ve meant feeling it.

“You. Perfect little life.” His voice had gone harsher, uglier. “God, I can’t stand being around you a second longer. You stuck-up, vapid bitch.”

He could still see the moment her face changed. Not anger. Not defensiveness. Just hurt settling in, heavy and quiet, like something inside her had just… broken, quietly.

Jamie opened his eyes. His breath was shallow.

He forced the words out. “I said something awful.”

Lena didn’t interrupt. She held perfectly still.

“I called you a bitch,” Jamie said, voice rough.

Lena flinched anyway, like the word still had teeth.

Jamie’s chest caved. “And you didn’t do anything. You were laughing.”

“I remember,” Lena said quietly.

Jamie swallowed hard. “I told myself you were laughing at me. That you thought it was funny. You weren’t. You were just… happy.”

Lena’s jaw flexed. Her voice was raw. “And then you wouldn’t talk to me.”

Jamie nodded once, shame heavy.

“I didn’t understand,” Lena said, carefully controlled. “One day you were you, and the next day you were gone. You didn’t even look at me like I was real.”

Jamie’s throat tightened. “I know.”

“Then why?” Lena demanded, and the control in her voice cracked, just a little. “Why did you do that to me?”

Jamie’s mouth went dry.

He could feel his heartbeat in his ears.

He couldn’t say the whole truth yet, not in one clean jump, but he couldn’t lie either.

“I was jealous,” he whispered.

Lena went still. “Jealous.”

Jamie nodded, shame burning. “And I hated myself for it. So I made it your problem.”

Lena stared at him like that was both too simple and too complicated.

“Jealous of what?” she asked, direct. No guessing games. No fishing. Just the question.

Jamie’s throat tightened.

He didn’t answer fast enough.

Lena leaned forward slightly. “Jamie.”

He exhaled, shaky. “I didn’t like what was happening to me.”

Lena’s eyes sharpened. “Your voice.”

Jamie nodded.

Lena’s expression shifted—confusion giving way to something careful, something horrified on his behalf. “You hated it.”

Jamie laughed, thin. “Yeah.”

Lena’s voice softened without losing its edge. “What did it feel like?”

Jamie stared at the bedspread, then forced himself to say it.

“It felt like I opened my mouth and a stranger came out,” he said quietly.

Lena’s breath hitched.

“And I couldn’t stop it,” Jamie added, the words scraping. “And every day I felt like I was becoming… less me.”

Silence.

Lena’s eyes shone, but she didn’t wipe them. She didn’t look away. She just held the moment steady.

Jamie’s hands clenched in her hoodie sleeves.

“I looked at you,” he said, voice shaking, “and I wanted those changes. Your hair, the curves starting, all of it. I wanted it so badly it made me feel insane.”

Lena’s face crumpled, quick and involuntary.

Jamie kept going, before he could chicken out. “And I didn’t have words. I didn’t know what that meant. I just knew I couldn’t stand hearing myself. I couldn’t stand pictures. I couldn’t stand—” He broke off, throat closing.

Lena’s voice went small. “So you took it out on me.”

Jamie nodded. “Yeah.”

Lena’s tears slid down her cheeks, silent. She finally wiped them with the heels of her hands, angry at herself for crying.

Then she took a breath.

“Were you trying to make me go away?” she asked.

Jamie hesitated.

Lena’s eyes narrowed. “Don’t lie.”

Jamie’s shoulders sank. “Yes.”

Lena’s face tightened, pain flashing.

Jamie rushed on, wrecked. “Because if you weren’t there, I didn’t have to watch it happening. I didn’t have to feel it. I didn’t have to—” He stopped, shaking.

Lena’s voice went softer, but not less intense. “Jamie. Why?”

His mouth opened.

Nothing came out.

His brain screamed, Don’t.

But Lena was right there.

And he was so tired.

Jamie’s voice came out raw. “Because you were turning into a woman,” he whispered, almost too quiet to hear, “and I wasn’t.”

Lena went completely still.

Jamie’s chest tightened so hard it hurt. He kept going before he could stop himself, the words spilling out like they’d been waiting behind his teeth for years.

“Because the distance between your life and mine was widening every day,” he said, shaking, “and I didn’t know how to say please without choking on it.”

Lena’s eyes widened. She didn’t interrupt.

“Because I knew what I wanted,” Jamie whispered, “and I was too dumb and too cowardly to admit it to anyone. Including myself out loud.”

Lena’s breath caught.

Jamie laughed, small and broken. “I knew. I just kept pretending I didn’t.”

Lena leaned forward an inch, careful not to startle him. “Jamie,” she said softly. “What did you want?”

Jamie went cold.

He could feel the hoodie on his shoulders. He could smell her. He could feel the Sailor Moon tee against his skin like a dare.

He swallowed the panic and forced the words out anyway.

“I wanted to be you,” he whispered.

Lena’s eyes filled instantly.

“Not you-you,” Jamie rushed, shame flooding. “I don’t want your life, I just— I wanted what you were becoming. I wanted—”

Lena’s voice shook. “Jamie…”

Jamie shut his eyes hard, then said it, because if he didn’t he never would.

“I wanted to be a girl,” he whispered.

The room went very quiet.

Jamie stared at the bedspread. Heart pounding so hard it made him dizzy. Waiting for recoil. For laughter. For the world to correct itself.

Instead Lena’s breath came out shaky.

Then her hand moved, slow and careful, and landed on his forearm through the sleeve of her hoodie. Not gripping. Not forcing. Just… there.

“Okay,” Lena whispered.

Jamie’s throat tightened painfully. “Okay?”

Lena nodded, tears spilling now without restraint. “Okay,” she said again, like she was making a promise. “Okay. I— okay.”

Jamie tried not to cry and failed. The tears came hot and humiliating.

Lena didn’t look disgusted.

Lena looked like she’d found the missing piece of a puzzle that had been cutting her fingers for years.

“You knew,” Lena whispered, voice thick. “You knew this whole time.”

Jamie’s shoulders hunched. “Yeah.”

“And you were alone with it,” Lena said.

Jamie nodded.

Lena’s voice went fierce, sudden. “No. No more.”

Jamie’s breath caught. “Lena—”

“I’m not saying you have to do anything,” Lena said quickly, like she heard his panic in the shape of his name. “I’m not saying you have to tell anyone. I’m not saying you have to—” She swallowed and softened. “I’m saying you don’t have to be alone with it.”

Jamie’s breath was shaky. “I don’t even— I don’t even know how to—”

“I can learn,” Lena said immediately. “We can learn. But I can hold it with you. Okay?”

Jamie blinked at her.

Lena’s eyes were wet and bright and stubborn. “Say yes,” she whispered. “Just… let me.”

Jamie’s throat worked. He nodded once. “Yes.”

Lena exhaled like she’d been holding her breath since he left.

Then she scooted closer and pulled him into her, firm and protective. Not the full tackle. Something steadier. Her arms wrapped around him like she was claiming him back from the years.

Jamie didn’t know what to do with his hands at first.

Then he clung back, shaking.

Lena pressed her cheek to the side of his head.

“Hey,” she murmured, voice breaking. “I’m sorry I didn’t see it.”

“You couldn’t have,” Jamie whispered.

“It wasn’t your job,” he added, because he needed her to believe it.

Lena pulled back just enough to look at him, eyes fierce. “It’s always been my job to love you.”

Jamie’s breath hitched.

He looked away fast, because that was too much.

Lena didn’t force him back. She just held him and kept her voice soft.

“Right now,” she asked quietly, “what do you need from me today? Not forever. Just today.”

Jamie stared at her like the question was written in another language.

“I don’t know,” he whispered.

Lena nodded. “Okay.”

Jamie’s voice came out smaller. “I want… this.”

“This,” Lena echoed, gentle.

Jamie gestured weakly at the hoodie, her bed, her arms. At the fact that he was sitting here in softness and it didn’t feel like a joke.

“I want to not be alone,” he said, shaking. “I want to not hate myself for five minutes.”

Lena nodded once. “Okay.”

Jamie swallowed. “And I want you to—” He stopped, panic flaring, because the next words were dangerous.

Lena waited, patient.

Jamie forced it out, barely audible. “I want you to keep… calling me what you called me earlier.”

Lena’s breath caught.

“Not in front of people,” Jamie rushed, cheeks burning. “Just— when it’s us. When you said it, it felt like I could breathe.”

Lena didn’t tease him. Didn’t make it weird.

She nodded, slow and solemn, like he’d handed her something holy.

“Okay,” she whispered.

Lena’s hand slid up to his cheek, gentle, and turned his face just slightly—no force, just bringing him back.

“My girl, my Princess,” she said softly, careful, like she was testing whether it would hurt him.

Jamie’s breath hitched.

Then his shoulders sagged, and he nodded, the smallest motion.

Lena’s voice shook. “Hi.”

Jamie’s eyes burned. “Hi.”

Lena let out a shaky laugh through tears. “Okay,” she breathed. “Okay.”

Then she went fierce again, cheeks pink. “You’re my person,” she said, like she needed him to hear it in plain English. “Not property. Not… weird. You’re my best friend. You don’t get to disappear.”

Jamie’s throat tightened. “Lena…”

Lena’s voice cracked. “I was physically sick for weeks after you left,” she whispered. “I felt like someone cut a piece out of my chest.”

Jamie went very still.

“So if we’re doing this,” Lena said, trembling, “we’re doing it together. You don’t have to sprint. You don’t have to do anything you’re not ready for. But you do not get to be alone with it.”

The fear didn’t vanish. It was still there, hot and sharp.

But there was something else now too.

A thin, trembling thread of relief.

Jamie’s voice was barely a whisper. “Okay.”

Lena nodded once, like a vow. “Okay.”

They sat like that for a long time. Lena kept one hand on his arm like she was afraid he’d evaporate. Jamie kept breathing, shaky but real.

After a while, Lena asked softly, “Do you want me to tell them?”

Jamie went rigid. “No.”

Lena nodded immediately. “Okay. Then I won’t.”

“Not yet,” Jamie managed.

“Not yet,” Lena echoed.

Jamie’s hands trembled in her hoodie sleeves. “I don’t know if I ever—”

Lena leaned in, forehead touching his for a brief second, grounding. “One day at a time,” she whispered. “Just one day at a time.”

Jamie nodded once.

And Lena pulled him back into her arms, firm and warm, like the world could wait outside her door for as long as it needed to.

Lena didn’t let go.

Not fully. Not even when Jamie’s breathing started to even out again. She stayed wrapped around him like she was bracing against something unseen, like the years might try to drag him back if she loosened her grip for even a second.

Jamie’s face was pressed into her shoulder. The varsity hoodie was bunched between them, her name half-hidden by his fingers. He could feel her heartbeat. Fast, but steadying.

His own heart still felt like it was trying to climb out of his ribs.

He’d said it.

Out loud.

The world hadn’t ended.

That thought was so strange his brain kept circling it, like a tongue poking a sore tooth.

Lena shifted, careful. She didn’t pull away so much as adjust, sliding her hand from his back to his cheek. Her touch was gentle in a way that made Jamie’s throat tighten all over again.

“Okay,” she whispered. “We’re going to do this the Lena Way.”

Jamie made a small sound that might’ve been a laugh. “What’s the Lena Way?”

“Logistics,” Lena said promptly, like it was obvious. Then her expression softened. “But, like… gentle logistics.”

Jamie blinked at her through wet lashes.

Lena wiped his cheek with her thumb, slow. “You don’t have to answer anything you don’t want to. If something feels like a trap, we don’t do it. If you start feeling floaty, you tell me.”

Jamie swallowed. “Floaty?”

“Like you’re leaving your body,” Lena said, jaw tightening. “Like you’re not here.”

Jamie flinched. He didn’t say yes. He didn’t say no.

Lena didn’t push. She just nodded once like she’d filed it away.

Then she asked, quietly, “Do you want me to keep calling you “Jamie”?”

Jamie blinked. The question was so simple it almost hurt.

He took a breath. “Yeah,” he said, voice rough. “Jamie is… fine.”

Lena nodded. “Okay.”

She waited a beat, then added, even softer, “Do you want a different name?”

Jamie’s stomach dipped. The concept of having a different name felt like standing at the edge of a cliff and looking down.

He shook his head once, firm. “No.”

“Okay,” Lena said immediately, no disappointment, no pressure. “No is perfect.”

Jamie’s shoulders loosened a fraction.

Lena’s fingers found the stitched letters on her hoodie again, absent-minded, grounding. “What about pronouns,” she asked, careful. “Just for us. In here. When it’s only us.”

Jamie’s throat tightened.

He stared at the space between them like it might offer him an escape route.

Part of him wanted it so badly it made his skin buzz.

Another part of him—older, louder, trained by fear—slammed the door and shouted that wanting wasn’t the same as deserving.

“I can’t ask for she,” Jamie whispered.

Lena went still.

Jamie’s voice shook. “I’m not a girl.”

The words landed between them like something fragile and sharp.

Lena’s eyes filled again, but her voice came out steady, immediate. “That doesn’t matter.”

Jamie blinked at her.

Lena leaned in, close enough that he could feel the warmth of her breath. “If you say you are, then you are,” she said, fierce and gentle at the same time. “You don’t have to earn it. There’s no test. There’s no… quota of suffering you have to hit first.”

Jamie’s breath caught.

“We do whatever makes you feel better,” Lena added, softer now, like she was speaking directly to the scared part of him. “That’s it. That’s the whole rule.”

Jamie’s eyes burned.

He looked away fast. “But—”

“No,” Lena said, not harsh. Just firm. “No buts. Not today.”

Silence.

Jamie’s hands trembled in the sleeves of her hoodie.

His voice came out smaller. “It would make me feel better.”

Lena’s face softened. “Okay,” she whispered. “Then we do that.”

Jamie swallowed hard. “Just… here.”

“Just here,” Lena promised.

He hesitated, then managed, ragged, “She. When it’s us.”

Lena’s breath shook. She nodded like she was receiving something precious and terrifying.

“Okay,” she whispered. “She.”

Jamie’s chest tightened painfully.

Lena cupped his cheek again, thumb brushing away a tear. “Jamie is a girl,” she said softly, like she was stating a fact the universe had been waiting to hear. Then her voice warmed, fierce and tender all at once. “She’s my girl, my Princess.”

Jamie’s breath caught hard.

It felt like stepping into warm water after being cold for so long you’d forgotten warmth existed.

A sound slipped out of him—small, broken, relieved.

Lena pulled him closer, arms wrapping tight.

“It’s okay,” she murmured into his hair. “It’s okay. You’re allowed. You’re allowed.”

Jamie shook in her arms. The words kept hitting something inside him, loosening it, like a knot finally giving way.

After a long minute, the crying eased into shaky breaths.

Lena didn’t move away. She didn’t look at the clock. She didn’t do anything except be there.

When Jamie could breathe again, Lena asked, quiet as a confession, “Is it okay if I ask one more thing?”

Jamie nodded, small.

Lena swallowed. “When you were in Chicago… did it get worse?”

Jamie’s stomach tightened. He stared at the hoodie sleeve pooled over his hands.

He didn’t want to lie. He also didn’t want to make her carry all of it at once.

So he chose the smallest honest answer.

“Yeah,” he whispered. “It got worse.”

Lena’s face pinched. “Did you have anyone at all?”

Jamie shook his head.

Lena’s eyes flashed, fury and grief rising together. She pressed her lips together hard, like she was trying not to say something reckless.

Instead she reached for his hand, laced their fingers together, and squeezed.

“I have you now,” she said, fierce and trembling. “Okay? I have you now.”

Jamie nodded, throat tight.

Lena breathed in, slow, then out. “Okay,” she said again, softer. “Next question is easier.”

Jamie’s voice was hoarse. “There are easier questions?”

Lena’s mouth twitched. “Yes. For example: do you want me to get back in bed and reapply cuddle lock for medical reasons.”

Jamie let out a shaky laugh. “Medical reasons.”

“Medical reasons,” Lena confirmed solemnly. Then her expression softened. “You don’t have to be brave right now. You’ve done enough.”

Jamie stared at her—at her puffy eyes, her messy hair, her fierce gentleness—and something inside him unclenched.

“Can we… just stay?” he whispered.

Lena’s gaze warmed. “Yeah,” she said, immediate. “Yeah, we can stay.”

She shifted back onto the bed and tugged him with her, firm and sure. She didn’t shove him flat this time. She guided him down like something precious.

Then she tucked herself behind him again, arms sliding around his waist, legs tangling with his, chin settling near his shoulder.

Cuddle lock: re-engaged.

Jamie let out a breath that sounded like surrender.

Lena kissed his temple. “Hi,” she whispered again, like she meant it new every time.

Jamie’s eyes closed.

“Thank you, Lele,” he whispered, voice rough with everything he couldn’t say. “Hi.”

57