The woman sighed as the bathroom door stayed shut in front of her, despite the promise of the occupant that it would be opened three minutes ago. Hell’s bells, how long does it take to put on a shirt, she thought to herself. After waiting another minute, she sighed once again and finally spoke.
“Hey, hon, you alright in there? Get lost on the way to the buttons or something?”
A slightly muffled reply came through the door. “Damn it, Dakota, don’t rush me! I’ll be out in just a minute.”
“You said that five minutes ago. And another five minutes before that too, for the record.” Silence served as her answer, prompting another sigh from the ever so slightly annoyed woman. “Look, I’m going to go sit on the bed. Just come in when you’re done, alright? I’m tired of standing out here.”
Dakota walked down through the slim hallway and opened the door to the bedroom with a quiet creak. The mattress springs groaned as she flopped herself down onto them, her annoyance quickly turning to worry for her girlfriend as she sat back up. It shouldn’t take her twenty minutes to change clothes, even if it is-
Dakota’s thoughts were cut short as her girlfriend suddenly appeared in the doorway, dressed to kill in a three piece suit. Her ginger hair was tied back in a high bun, helping ever so slightly to draw attention away from her shoulders tenseness, which was showing through even with the three layers of cloth over them. Dakota’s eyes wandered lower, drinking in the (in her opinion) marvelous view. An immaculate windsor knot sat on top of the fully buttoned collar, explaining the long wait she had to endure.
A cough rang out, breaking Dakota’s silent stare. The nerves that had already been eating away at her girlfriend were even more obvious as she spoke in a quiet, shaky voice. “Um, how-how do I look? Is it bad?”
“Oh, Sylvia, no. I promise you, you look amazing.”
Sylvia’s shoulders stayed tense, her mind refusing to believe it after spending so long staring in the mirror to tie her tie correctly. “Y-you really mean that?”
“I promise you, I mean it with every part of me. You’re gorgeous.” An ever so slight wince crossed Sylvia’s face at that, a small pain that would have been impossible to see by the average observer. But Dakota was no average observer. “You’re still not crazy about being called gorgeous, huh?”
“I app-preciate the compliment, I really do!”
“Never said you didn’t.”
Sylvia gave Dakota her best puppy dog eyes to try and weasel out of having to answer, a stern concerned but caring look being her only response. She sighed as she sought the words to try and articulate a subject that slipped out of her hands like a live fish every time she tried to explain it. “I just… I just thought I’d grow into them, you know?”
“I’m afraid I don’t. Can you explain it more for me? It’s okay if you can’t.”
Sylvia shot a glance at the bed, asking for permission to sit down. Dakota scooted over and patted the mattress to the left of her, simultaneously making room for her and inviting her over. She walked over and sat as she undid the button of her suit jacket, still trying to pick out the right words that seemed to be impossible to find. “It’s just like… look, let me ask you a question. When you first realized you were maybe not a guy and you started letting yourself explore the other options, did you ever feel like you didn’t deserve the things that came with that exploring? Like using she/her, even just in your own head.”
“Uh, yeah, a bit. I feel like that particular combination of imposter syndrome and dysphoria is almost universal, honestly.”
Sylvia nodded slightly, eyes shifting from her girlfriend to the carpet as her seemingly never-ending quest for words continued. “It might be, yeah. But, but, that is what it is. It’s imposter syndrome and dysphoria and the feeling that you can’t feel like something other than utter shit because that's how you’ve gone through all of your life so far. And you grow out of it or maybe over it you know? You realize that you don’t have to earn them and you come to like them and have no problem with using them all the time with everyone. Is this even making any sense?”
“It is, yeah.”
“I just always thought that everything else would be like that too, you know? I just thought I’d grow into skirts and makeup and being called things like ‘gorgeous’ and ‘good girl’ and shit like that.”
Worry flashed on Dakota’s face before she forced it back into a neutral position. “Do you not like being referred to as a woman? It’s okay if you don’t, you don’t have to pretend to for my sake especially if it’s hurting you.”
“It’s not that I don’t like being a woman or being referred to as one, as much as I don’t like it being emphasized? Like, if I’m at work and someone says ‘she’s over there’ or calls me a woman I like that. I like being a woman in casual conversation, but being a woman in intimate conversation just still doesn’t feel like me.”
“Can I ask you a question? And please don’t be upset by me asking it.”
“I promise I won’t. Go ahead.”
“Have you considered stopping HRT? Just to see how you feel off of it now that you’ve had more time on it?”
Another sigh left Sylivia’s mouth. Five in one day, approaching her record. “I can’t say I haven’t, because I have but I don’t want to and I’m not going to. I know you never knew me when I was running on testosterone, but it wasn’t great to put it mildly. I barely made it to eighteen to be able to sign my own consent forms. T’s great for a lotta people, but I ain’t one of them.”
Dakota nodded, at a loss of words herself. The couple sat in silence for a moment, Dakota laying her hand over Sylvia’s before she quietly spoke up once again. “So, what do you want then?”
“What do you mean?”
“What I mean is that you’ve spent the past few minutes listing off all of these things that you never liked and thought you would, so what do you like? What have you grown into?”
Sylvia chuckled as she averted her eyes once again. “Babe, there ain’t no point in daydreaming as nice as it might be. You spit out the back window, you’ll hit West Virginia. Spit out the front window, a transphobic republican. I have to look and act a certain way to be safe, same as you do, so there ain’t no point in pretending I don’t.”
Now it was Dakota’s turn to imitate a puppy, a tactic Sylvia was far more susceptible to. “Please, for me? Just think of what you could do whenever we can finally move to Lexington to let you finish your degree.”
A sixth sigh, a new personal record of Sylvia’s. “Fine, fine. I guess I’d want to look more like my namesake, Sylvia Scarlett.”
“Wait a minute, wait a minute! Out of all the movies Katharine Hepburn made, you named yourself after that Katharine Hepburn movie? That movie was awful!”
Sylvia was indignant at the mocking of her namesake. “Look, I’ll admit that the film isn’t great from a plot standpoint-”
“What other standpoint is there?”
Sylvia continued louder at her girlfriend's interruption, a small smile gracing her face in response to the behavior. “-But, she is amazing in it. Plus, how she looks with her hair done for that terrible, terrible plot? She’s - I don’t even know the word, honestly. But, it’s wonderful.”
“Handsome,” Dakota suggested quietly.
“Handsome… yeah, handsome. She was very handsome in that film.”
Dakota saw an opportunity and knew she had to take it. She just hoped it wouldn’t explode in her face. “But not as handsome as you in that suit.”
A smile appeared on Sylvia’s face while her eyes showed nothing but disbelief. “You’re just saying that because you know I like it, even though it’s not true.”
Dakota’s hand moved from laying on top of Sylvia’s to gently hold the edge of her tie, her thumb running back and forth over the front as it got acquainted with the material. “Now, there’s that dysphoria denying the truth you mentioned earlier.” Sylvia laughed at that, the smile slowly creeping up to her eyes. Dakota said a quick prayer in her head that she hadn’t misread what her girlfriend had just said before she continued. “So, tell me, how long did it take you to tie this knot, pretty boy?”
Sylvia’s eyes widened and her cheeks flushed hot as her mouth tried to stutter out a response. Dakota grinned like a Cheshire cat at being right. Eventually, and with great difficulty, Sylvia managed to stutter out “W-what?”
Dakota wrapped the tie around her hand, slowly bringing Sylvia in closer to her face as she spoke. “What I asked is how long did this knot take you, pretty boy?”
Their faces were inches apart, Sylvia’s still radiating heat from its red color and Dakota’s grin never having disappeared even as she slightly tilted her head. “F-fif-fifteen minutes.”
“Want to see how long it takes me to ruin it?”
“Pl-please.”
“As you wish, handsome.” Dakota murmured just before she planted a kiss on Sylvia’s lips and pulled her down onto the bed on top of her by her tie.
Well I can see why you're getting the gender envy, she looks fiiiine
If you really want to put a name on it, sounds like some kinda enby, but like, don't feel you have to yknow? Sometimes gender just be Like That and you should just ride along :]
I've got no sense to share, other than it seems wonderful and person-like. people can be very weird, in good ways. There's plenty of variety. Sometimes it can be very hard to find the little corner that you belong in.
Actually, no, I do have some sense: take care of yourself, and don't feel obligated by others: not to stay where you are, not to move the way other people do. You're you, not them. If they judge you, that speaks more about themselves than anything about you.
Holy shit, author thank you so much for this, Sylvia's gender feelings sound so similar to mine, and I see so little of that kind of thing on this website so this is wonderful. I'm sorry to hear you've been having trouble understanding yourself, but if this story is reflective of that, then I seriously think that my own perspective could be useful.
The short answer is: butch! I identify as butch, and its one of the parts of myself that I'm happiest and most passionate about. I think it can initially be hard to reconcile the cultural view of trans women as steeped in femininity with the fact that a trans woman can be butch, can like to have short hair and wear masculine clothes and like being called handsome, but it's a thing! Gender nonconformity and transness have always gone hand in hand, and butch women and trans women have a heck of a lot in common (I should know, I'm both!) once you put aside bioessentialist ideas about what it means to be trans. Since the beginning of my transition butchness and gnc lesbian culture in general have been my guiding lights in understanding and accepting myself, since it's always been butch women that I've felt the most drawn to, both in a gender identity way and an attraction way. I'd never heard of Sylvia Scarlette before, but looking it up and I can confirm that that's exactly the sort of movie little egg me would have loved.
I would never want to try to assign a label to another person or anything like that, since your identity is entirely up to you, but given how much I connected with Sylvia it felt right to share this part of me. If you're curious to hear more about it, I'm always happy to talk! I also recommend scrolling through r/mtfButch if you want to see some very handsome and inspirational women. This youtube video: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rB7li47ZS5k is also great for this sort of thing and was put up around the same time that I got my hair cut short too, so I feel a bit of a kindred spirit with her lol
Regardless of everything I said, this was a lovely little story to read, and I look forward to whatever you decide to write and whoever you decide to be! :)
Okay, so sorry in advance as this probably is gonna be kinda long and maybe a bit tmi, but not the gross kind, just the “holy sh*t someone else gets it” way.
The timing of your comment couldn’t be more perfect as I literally went and chopped most of my hair off today (it was at my midback and is now just above my shoulders so you can get an idea of how much I had removed) and was trying to deal with the fact that the short time I’ve had this new haircut has given me more euphoria than the rest of my hair ever gave me in the two and a half years to I spent grow it out.
I was even planning a second chapter to this story based off of my experiences today about hair and underwear and voice stuff just to try and get my head to stop focusing on it. I’m still going to write it but with this new knowledge rattling around in my head and influencing it, so I hope you don’t mind hearing more about mine and Sylvia’s gender shit.
That is why I wrote this story by the way, to just try to get my feelings out of my head so I could try and deal with them in a more objective way. Sylvia is me and I’m her. The question of is Sylvia, and therefore me, butch is a much more difficult question than “is Sylvia me” however.
I just never felt like I could use the butch label, as it just felt like a thing only for cis lesbians not to mention how I thought I had to be in order to be a trans woman. I mean, I guess for a long I just thought transitioning didn’t have a point if I didn’t change to be a typical woman. If that even makes any sense. I’m gonna go look at that subreddit, might even post a selfie or a question if I can work up the guts. So, thanks.
This is wonderful to hear, I'm so glad my comment touched on something for you, and happy to hear about your experiences with expression as well haha. Chopping your hair off is literally so much fun
Looking forward to the next chapter and any other updates! I love yelling about butchness and am free to do so whenever needed lol
Conditional genderfluidity is definitely a thing