A/N: Here's the new Chapter! Which also means the next four chapters are up on my Patreon for early access as well as the chance to vote on the direction of the story!

Tara joins in on the fun after all, but the surprise is WHO winds up getting her involved...

-x-X-x-

Lucien finds himself in quite a moral quandary. On the one hand, he already defended Tara’s preferences to Blackfire and Starfire, making it abundantly clear that he would not let them bully the human girl into doing anything she didn’t want to do or wasn’t sexually aroused by.

On the other hand, he really wanted Tara’s biology at some point. Sure, he could definitely just find a reason to touch her in a more platonic matter later, especially if he kept hanging out and fighting alongside the Titans, since she would inevitably get injured at some point. But he had an opportunity right here and right now… and he wasn’t sure she’d really go for him saying ‘sorry, can’t fuck you, but here’s a handshake and let’s be friends’. That felt like it would be more than just a little suspicious.

On the third, eldritch hand that he COULD have made burst out of his chest with his powers if he wanted to… Lucien didn’t want to piss off Blackfire either. Maybe nobody else in the room knew this, but he’d been in some sort of weird partnership with Blackfire long before meeting Starfire or Terra. So sure, Starfire might actually legitimately want to let him fuck her teammate, and the Amnesiac Blackfire might be willing to go along with it because she didn’t think she had much of a claim to him… but that wasn’t entirely true and Lucien had to take all of this into account.

In the end, he lets out a soft sigh and shakes his head.

“I’m sorry Tara, but I don’t think I can give you what you want. Not and stay true to Starfire and Blackfire. Unless you can see yourself sharing me with them, I just don’t think I can leave their side to be with you, even with their permission. It… doesn’t feel right.”

Starfire flushes at that, looking towards her sister and likely finally realizing that Blackfire wasn’t onboard with all of this as she’d initially assumed. Blackfire also flushes and then scowls at him, opening her mouth to say something… but before she can, Tara pipes up.

“I… I u-understand. I shouldn’t have… I shouldn’t have asked. I-I shouldn’t have even watched. I’m sorry for spying on all of you like that. I-!”

The young blonde geokinetic looks ready to bolt when suddenly Blackfire growls from over on the bed.

“Ugh! This is ridiculous!”

Pushing up off of her lounging position finally, using a bit of her flight to do so, Blackfire floats up off the bed and touches down on the floor. Her hands are on her hips as she stands there fully nude, with Terra flushing and averting her gaze.

“You had no problem spying on us while we fucked, did you human?”

“I-I… n-no?”

“You enjoyed watching Lucien fuck us, didn’t you? You probably fantasized about being in our place, yes?”

“… yes.”

“Then you should have no problem with us being in the room while he fucks you.”

Tara pauses, not looking… immediately disgusted by the idea.

“Likewise, you should have no issue with us helping to pleasure Lucien while you do the same.”

That though, gets a wrinkled nose from the blonde. But Blackfire just bulldozes right past that expression.

“There are plenty of ways for two or even three women to share a man without actually touching or pleasuring each other, human. What it really comes down to is just how badly you want to fuck Lucien. Are you willing to let us watch? Are you willing to let us fuck him too? I can even promise that neither my sister nor I will ever so much as touch you if it makes you feel better.”

Wow. Where was all this coming from? It takes Lucien a second to realize… it’s because of him. Just like he was smart enough to realize Blackfire wasn’t happy about the thought of him going off and fucking another woman even with Starfire’s permission, it seems Blackfire was smart enough to realize that the only reason he had chosen not to do so was because of her.

So now here she was, trying to find a way to make everything work… not for herself, but for him. Well now, that was certainly something wasn’t it?

In the time it takes Lucien to figure that out, Tara is quiet. But finally, she slowly nods.

“I… o-okay. I could try that…”

Blackfire smirks.

“Perfect. Then strip.”

Tara flinches at that, flushing for a moment. In response, Blackfire scowls and takes a step back, gesturing to Lucien.

“Lucien, tell the little human trollop to strip already!”

Moving over to the bed, Blackfire grabs her sister by the hair and pulls Starfire in close. She whispers instructions to her, instructions that Lucien can’t help overhearing. But it’s nothing too bad, so he stays quiet about it as he looks at Terra of the Titans, his cock twitching in anticipation.

“Tara Markov. Strip for me.”

That seems to do the trick for her, because the blonde steadily begins taking off her clothes. She tries to make it a strip tease, not quite dancing but definitely attempting to accentuate her body as she exposes herself to him. And to be fair, it’s not a half bad body at all. She’s cute in a tomboy sort of way. Not as voluptuous as Starfire or Blackfire, and she doesn’t even have a hefty ass like Raven, but she’s got some curves and a lean, lithe build that Lucien can appreciate all the same.

He's not even sure he has a type, truth be told. Unless one counted Death, that is. In comparison to her, everyone else was just a little bit lacking, weren’t they? But that wasn’t their fault. And Lucien certainly didn’t hold it against them.

Once Tara is completely naked, she bites her lower lip, covering herself with her hands in a self-conscious fashion despite the slightly awkward strip tease she’d been engaging in mere moments ago.

Coming up behind him, Blackfire hugs him from behind and brings her lips to his ear.

“Have her crawl to you.”

“On your hands and knees, Tara. Crawl over here. You’ve been a bad girl after all… it’s time you make up for that.”

Tara’s blush intensifies magnificently at his words and she flinches hard, but she nods nonetheless. Spying on them? Peeping like that? He’s not wrong. She HAS been a bad girl and she has a lot to make up for. Dropping down to her hands and knees, she crawls over to him… only pausing briefly when Starfire starts to do the same. Both Titans are on all fours as they crawl towards him, with Starfire crawling down off the bed in the process.

They reach him at around the same time, though the Tamaranean beauty is first. She takes up position kneeling on one side of his cock and Tara, following her lead, kneels on the other side of his cock. The blonde human is still definitely more interested in Lucien than she is in Starfire to be fair, looking up at him in between glancing at his throbbing erection and pulsing balls.

Of course, when Kori leans forward and starts to submissively and dutifully lick up and down her side of his cock, Tara all but leaps to do the same. It’s just as Blackfire had said. A threesome can be all about the guy, with the two girls not interacting in any way. Lucien isn’t very used to that of course, mostly because his only threesomes have been with Starfire and Blackfire at this point… but it’s working.

The only thing is, Starfire is having to clasp her hands behind her back in the process, likely afraid that she’ll get handsy with Terra if she doesn’t. In turn, Terra just has her hands on her lap, the blonde biokinetic paying Starfire absolutely no mind as she licks up and down his cock. Well, not NO mind. There’s a competitiveness to how the blonde Titan is acting, Lucien quickly notes. Like she wants to beat Starfire, like she wants to impress him or something.

“Adorable.”

Blackfire’s voice in his ear almost makes him jolt. He hadn’t necessarily forgotten she was there of course. Kind of hard to with her tits pressed into his back and her hands running up and down his chest. But he’d definitely focused more on Starfire and Terra for a moment.

“Put her in her place, Lucien. Take her over to the bed and rail her silly. Make her your bitch. We can introduce her to the concept of pleasuring her female betters at a later date~”

All of this is said too quietly for Terra to hear, of course. At the same time, as much as Blackfire’s promises make him throb even harder, he won’t let her force the issue. But they can burn that bridge when they come to it. For now… he’s so fucking hard and ready to go that taking the alien princess’ advice sounds like a great idea.

Reaching out, he places his hands atop the heads of the two Titans currently licking, kissing, and lapping at his cock and stops them in their tracks.

“I’m going to fuck Tara now. Tara… get on the bed.”

“Y-Yes… yes sir…”

So submissive already. Was that because she really felt guilty over how naughty she’d been? Or was she just convinced that it was the kind of thing he liked? Well, she wasn’t wrong. Lucien’s cock twitches as the blonde human disengages and crawls over to the bed, getting up onto it on all fours. Her tomboy physique doesn’t really lend itself to being in that position though, he notes. Her back can’t quite arch the proper way, unfortunately.

But that’s okay. When he reaches the bed after her, Lucien wastes no time in flipping Tara over onto her back, causing the blonde to squeak in surprise. He pushes her legs up and to the sides as he moves between her thighs, his cock slapping down on her juicy wet cunt. She clearly looks surprised to be facing him for this. And embarrassed.

Lucien doesn’t give her time to dwell on it though. Even as he hears Blackfire fingering and murmuring to Starfire behind him, fondling the other young woman and playing with her body, Lucien thrusts forward into Tara, taking her virginity. Tara Markov cries out as her hymen is torn, feeling some small amount of pain for a moment. He makes sure it’s drowned out by pleasure though with his powers, tweaking the right bits of her biology just as he’d done with both Blackfire and Starfire once upon a time to make it feel oh so good.

Then… he starts to fuck her. Admittedly, his cheating might have exactly the effect that Blackfire is hoping for, Lucien realizes. If he makes sex with him TOO good for Tara, she might find herself associating her pleasure with the presence of the two Tamaranean Women as well. She also might find herself so desperate for his cock that she’d be willing to… try new things.

He wasn’t going to make her bisexual or anything like that though just to make things smoother. Either she was wired that way or she wasn’t. Fucking with Blackfire’s mind, blocking so many of her memories… that was something Lucien had ONLY done with consent. Unless the situation was life or death, he didn’t think he could bring himself to use that aspect of his powers… especially not on something like this. That felt like something his father might do. And Lucien Luthor was not his father.

With that in mind, he makes Tara cum and cum for him. He fucks her silly, enjoying the way her lithe, toned figure ripples and shudders beneath him. Her chest isn’t big enough to bounce that much even with how hard he’s fucking her, but it still jiggles slightly and the rest of her is bouncing more than enough to satisfy his base impulses. On top of that, her nipples are soon rock hard, standing out and protruding from her small breasts as she moans up a storm, sweating profusely in the process.

As Tara’s eyes roll up in her head and her tongue lolls out of her mouth from the pleasure, both Blackfire and Starfire climb onto the bed as well. True to Blackfire’s word, neither of them moves towards Tara or touches the blonde Titan in any way. Instead, they rub themselves against his body, egging him on each in their own way, moaning into his ears as they tell him to fuck Tara all the more soundly.

Lucien had no intentions of letting up anyways. He’s going to fuck Tara Markov. But he won’t stop there either. Koriandr and Komandr are both next. They’re all going to fucking get it and get it good before he’s through. That’s a promise.

-x-X-x-

Hours later, Lucien lays back on the bed having made good on his promise. Not that anyone even knew he’d made said promise since he’d only really made it to himself. Still, he’s done it. He’s fucked not just Tara, but also Kori and her sister into stupors. He’s plowed all three of them until they couldn’t think straight and railed them all into unconsciousness.

Alas, if only sleep would come so easily for him. Well, technically he could make himself fall asleep at any point he wanted to. He just didn’t want to. Instead, what he really wanted to do… was mess with his own biology.

He might have held off after getting Raven’s demon DNA, but acquiring access to Terra had left him feeling like he was burning a hole in his pocket with all of these options. He still hadn’t even used Beast Boy’s biology to enhance himself yet! Having gained a blueprint to Terra’s geokinesis the moment that her tongue first touched his cock, Lucien finds himself at a crossroads.

Should he stick to his guns and avoid too many changes before finishing with Starfire and Blackfire? Should he start messing around and experimenting? Was it worth trying to get in touch with Death to ask for her advice? He didn’t think he’d ever actually managed to consciously talk to her yet. It had all been involuntary so far. But it had also been a while since Lucien had heard from her, so maybe it was about that time?

The only problem was, he knew he wasn’t ready yet. He wanted to make Death cum, but as he currently was without any of the upgrades from the Titans, he was confident he would fail.

He could use his powers to put himself to sleep while focusing oh so very hard on Death of the Endless… or he could start incorporating some of his new gains right here and right now to make himself stronger before doing so.

… Hmm, tough call.

[ ] Try to contact Death for advice on how to best augment himself - 46%